storage myth?
storage myth?
Just looking for a few opinions here on this one... Has anyone ever heard of tying your clutch pedal and steering levers back while storing these old crawlers or any other equipment. It was suggested to me to prevent linings from "sticking or freezing-up" to flywheel or pressure plate. I have had a stuck clutch before on another tractor but was able to free-up while being towed in gear and jumping on both brakes as hard as I could with the clutch pedal strapped down. (sure felt lucky... after about a hour I thought I was going to have to split the tractor apart, then finally she broke free)
Thanks for any tips or advice
Thanks for any tips or advice
-
- 1010 crawler
- Posts: 301
- Joined: Tue Oct 02, 2007 1:08 pm
- Location: rhode island
dry clutch
I have heard a hundred different ways to store the dry clutch machines,to avoid the steering clutches rusting up,I startup and use the machine at least once a month for a little,even if using a rubber tired tractor makes more sense,the worst thing for any machine is to set unused for a period of time.
1010 loader
My 2010 has a dry clutch system. I asked the very same spring wear question and the response at the time was mixed about the pros/cons.
I started propping the levers back about 6 months ago after hearing the horror stories. In fact, prior to doing so I had one clutch stick after two weeks of non-use after a particularly humid and cold period, even covered. Thus, I started propping the levers back.
So far I have not had any problems with clutch weakness.
I agree that frequent use (weekly or better) combined with covering should make propping back unnecessary but don't want to take the risk since my use is intermittent and the crawler is covered but not garaged.
I started propping the levers back about 6 months ago after hearing the horror stories. In fact, prior to doing so I had one clutch stick after two weeks of non-use after a particularly humid and cold period, even covered. Thus, I started propping the levers back.
So far I have not had any problems with clutch weakness.
I agree that frequent use (weekly or better) combined with covering should make propping back unnecessary but don't want to take the risk since my use is intermittent and the crawler is covered but not garaged.
(1) JD Straight 450 crawler dozer with manual outside blade; (2) JD 2010 diesel crawler loaders; (1) JD 2010 diesel dozer with hydraulic 6-way blade; (2) Model 50 backhoe attachments, misc. other construction equipment
- Stan Disbrow
- 350 crawler
- Posts: 2898
- Joined: Fri Jul 15, 2005 3:13 pm
- Location: Raleigh, NC
Hi,
It seems to me that if left alone, the water vapor and oxygen in the air will have a harder time getting to the mating surfaces of the fiber and steel discs and screwing them up. If one props the levers back, that just opens up the space between the discs and would allow the offending gases greater penetration and cause the problems faster.
We (meaning my dad and now I) have not ever propped the levers back on the old 420c and have never had any form of sticking issues with the steering clutches since 1965 when dad forst got the old girl. It has not always been shedded, either, and has been known to sit for 3 or 4 months at a time without being used......
Stan
It seems to me that if left alone, the water vapor and oxygen in the air will have a harder time getting to the mating surfaces of the fiber and steel discs and screwing them up. If one props the levers back, that just opens up the space between the discs and would allow the offending gases greater penetration and cause the problems faster.
We (meaning my dad and now I) have not ever propped the levers back on the old 420c and have never had any form of sticking issues with the steering clutches since 1965 when dad forst got the old girl. It has not always been shedded, either, and has been known to sit for 3 or 4 months at a time without being used......
Stan
There's No Such Thing As A Cheap Crawler!
Useta Have: '58 JD 420c 5-roller w/62 inside blade
Useta Have: '78 JD350C w/6310 outside blade
Useta Have: '68 JD350, '51 Terratrac GT-25
Have: 1950 M, 2005 x495, 2008 5103 (now known as 5045D)
Useta Have: '58 JD 420c 5-roller w/62 inside blade
Useta Have: '78 JD350C w/6310 outside blade
Useta Have: '68 JD350, '51 Terratrac GT-25
Have: 1950 M, 2005 x495, 2008 5103 (now known as 5045D)
I have one tractor that the owner manual recommends blocking the clutch pedal down if the tractor is to be sitting for any amount of time. At first I diregarded this little piece of advice and lo and behold my clutch stuck. I was able to get it to free up with a little effort though. Ever since then the pedal gets blocked, I have been doing that now for the past 15 years and the clutch is still good. On a side note that particular tractor came out with a prop rod on later models.
All of my equipment sits in barns and out of the weather.
I haven't done that on my 2010 yet because I never even thought about it.
It does make since though. I do try to get around and fire up everything I own at least once a month.
Stretch
All of my equipment sits in barns and out of the weather.
I haven't done that on my 2010 yet because I never even thought about it.
It does make since though. I do try to get around and fire up everything I own at least once a month.
Stretch
2010C Dozer, 2010C Loader
If at first you don't succeed, get a bigger hammer.
If at first you don't succeed, get a bigger hammer.
Thanks to everyone for the replies- seems to be some mixed feelings, as expected. I have also heard of folks backing off valve springs for extended storage and leaving single cyl (motorcycles, generators, etc) on TDC. I think everyone agrees regular use is best, but if unable the question is whether this will compromise the pressure plate or not. I think the rust from moisture "allowed in" should not be an issue, it would get cleaned back up with a little use, (like a brake rotor does). Any more thoughts?
- FarmLife
- 430 crawler
- Posts: 98
- Joined: Tue Aug 28, 2007 8:55 pm
- Location: Saint Clair, Michigan
- Contact:
I think that if you are going to store it on concrete in a building then I really wouldn't worry about it as much. But I tihnk that you could just hold the clutch down about half way that way it would be easier on the springs but even if it did rust it should be completely stuck like it would be with full pressure on it.
1934 GP Beaner
1935 B
1935 AR
1935 AO
1936 B
1936 D
1935 A on skeletons
1937 A w/behlen overdrive
1939 B
1940 B
1941 H
1949 M
1954 40 Standard
1953 60 Regular
1955 70 Std Diesel
1954 80
1946 Lindeman
Phase 1 420
1935 B
1935 AR
1935 AO
1936 B
1936 D
1935 A on skeletons
1937 A w/behlen overdrive
1939 B
1940 B
1941 H
1949 M
1954 40 Standard
1953 60 Regular
1955 70 Std Diesel
1954 80
1946 Lindeman
Phase 1 420
Thanks digitup, and everyone. I have only replaced about 10 different clutches in my days and they were all due to oil saturation, preventive because I had it apart, or just worn linings... Im not sure if Ive ever done a clutch because of pressure plate not holding. I guess that my main concern is whether or not the pressure plate will lose holding power if stored with fingers depressed. I hate to find out the hard way (like usual).
My 40c will basically sit unused every year from about late October to March. Other than battery care, fluid changes, and a lot of wd-40 any other suggestions?
My 40c will basically sit unused every year from about late October to March. Other than battery care, fluid changes, and a lot of wd-40 any other suggestions?
I took the 40C for a romp the other night and a couple of hired men took turns around the shop after .It sat long enough to have the clutches go stiff it takes very little time to get the faces to rust in the humid conditions around here . I will get these guys to work on it they got a real kick out of something that they considered taking up space in the shop till now .Digitup.
-
- 1010 crawler
- Posts: 301
- Joined: Tue Oct 02, 2007 1:08 pm
- Location: rhode island
the 1010 sat for about 3 months and when I went to use it,one steering clutch was sticking and acting weird,ran for about an hour before it cleared up.
ever since I make a point of running it around for awhile about once a month.
seen a 350 so bad once the disc,fibers and hub became welded into one lump of rust.
ever since I make a point of running it around for awhile about once a month.
seen a 350 so bad once the disc,fibers and hub became welded into one lump of rust.
1010 loader
I think a lot of the tie the steering lever back stories are relating to crawlers that do not have coordinated steering like the Deere's. If you tie a Deere back, you get limited movement, mininal pressure reduction on the pressure plate, and you are applying the brake. On the other brands, you can pull the lever back all the way to the seat and remove all the pressure on the steering clutches without applying any brake.
Lavoy
Lavoy
Are you sure all the cover plates are in place? My 420 sits outside year-round through rain and humid summers in South Texas. It may sit for a couple of months or more between uses. I've never tied anything back or down. I guess I've been lucky but it fires up and goes to work on a moments notice.
JD420C, Ford 3910, IH 2606, Kenbota G32XKS
Thanks for all the feedback- With this machine (40c) I have not had any problems yet. I was warned from the previous owner that they had pulled the right side twice and the left final once because of condensation rusting the clutch lining to the pressure plate. I keep it undercover but have kept my "ears open" for advice... which was suggested to tie levers back. After Lavoys explanation it seems a waste of effort and maybe could freeze brake band? Wasnt sure and just fishing for ideas to prevent any headaches. Top vents are clear and I cut new gaskets just in case, bungs are tight.
Lavoy- any benefit to securing with the clutch pedal depressed or is it all unnecessary?
Lavoy- any benefit to securing with the clutch pedal depressed or is it all unnecessary?
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 127 guests